Patently-O
- Indefiniteness: Claiming a Measurement Without the Test MethodPatently-O ·
Federal Circuit: claims reciting a vapor transmission range of 600 to 11,000 g/m2/day are indefinite where the patent lists three test methods.
- Rule 60(d) Independent Actions and the Conversion of Merits Into JurisdictionPatently-O ·
How the Federal Circuit turned the Beggerly merits standard for Rule 60(d) independent actions into a limit on subject matter jurisdiction.
- Federal Circuit Reversal Rates by Tribunal: District Courts vs. the PTABPatently-O ·
Since 2021 the Federal Circuit changed 33% of district court patent judgments but only 19% of PTAB trial decisions; the two rates were equal in 2021, and the gap since comes from the district court side.
- 18 Years of Federal Circuit Mandamus: The Rise and Fall of the Texas Venue SurgePatently-O ·
In re Google (Oct. 6, 2026) was the Federal Circuit's first mandamus grant since In re Honeywell in January 2024, after 107 straight denials, and every grant since 2019 came from a Texas venue fight.
- The Director Returns IPR Merits to the PTABPatently-O ·
Duffy and Dolin join the USPTO legal team as the Director returns IPR merits decisions to PTAB panels and splits institution from trial.
- Don’t Get Me Started: High Cost of a Lopsided BenchPatently-O ·
New study of 7,000 Federal Circuit appeals reveals a clear trend: the more judges speak during a party's oral argument, the lower the win rate.
- The Wait for Oral Argument at the Federal CircuitPatently-O ·
Federal Circuit appeals that reach oral argument now wait about 19 months from docketing, up from 11 in 2021. The added time comes after briefing.
- Visiting Judges Return to the Federal CircuitPatently-O ·
Visiting judges are back on Federal Circuit panels: 17% of 2026 merits decisions had one, as the wait for argument nearly doubled.
- Self Citations in the Federal JudiciaryPatently-O ·
Study of self-citations in the federal judiciary by Jason Reinecke and Jason Rantanen.
- CAFC Citation HistoryPatently-O ·
Video showing the cases that the Federal Circuit cites most often going from 1983 to 2026
- Clear but Absurd: The Federal Circuit Searches for a Middle Ground in Vicor v. ITCPatently-O ·
Can a court rescue a party from a clear but ridiculously broad contract term? Judge Dyk floats a middle reading of a boilerplate patent license.
- Who Pays for the 500 Million COVID Doses? Section 1498 in Arbutus v. ModernaPatently-O ·
Arbutus v. Moderna asks whether government-bought COVID vaccines given to the public were made "for the Government" under Section 1498. Argument is Nov. 5.
- Self-Citation in Federal Circuit OpinionsPatently-O ·
Federal Circuit judges cite their own earlier opinions about 1.9 times as often as colleagues cite them, a gap that tracks who wrote the opinion.
- A Patent License by Purchase OrderPatently-O ·
Did a one-line ship-date email give Foxconn a royalty-free license to Vicor's patent? The Federal Circuit hears the battle-of-the-forms appeal Nov. 3.
- Guest Post by Profs. Masur & Ouellette: Public Use, Sales, and Public Disclosure Under the AIAPatently-O ·
Guest post by Professors Jonathan S. Masur (UChicago Law) and Lisa Larrimore Ouellette (Stanford Law).
- Oral Args at the Federal Circuit: Seven Patent Appeals on Nov 2, 2026Patently-O ·
Monday's Federal Circuit patent arguments: IPR disclaimer, BRI in reexam, link aggregation, and eligibility for turbine and location claims.
- Building the Internet We Want: Law for a Connected WorldPatently-O ·
Prof Dennis Crouch introduces Building the Internet We Want, a new book on speech, privacy, AI, contracts and the laws shaping our digital lives.
- The En Banc Queue for October 2026Patently-O ·
Eight en banc petitions are pending at the Federal Circuit, though two are pro se.
- The Wait for a First Action, by TechnologyPatently-O ·
First-action waits by technology family: about 34 months in bioinformatics, 12 in packaging, and 4 for Track One, with a full art unit table.
- Design Patent Infringement Test Heads Toward the Supreme CourtPatently-O ·
Range of Motion's cert petition, due Dec. 21, will challenge the plainly dissimilar test and judicial functionality findings for design patents.
- Revived and Forgotten: Should This Patent Issue?Patently-O ·
The USPTO revived IBM's allowed application in 2015 and never printed it. Should it now issue with 11 years of added term, or is the delay on Lenovo?
- The Wait for a First ActionPatently-O ·
The average wait from filing to a first action on the merits has fallen from about 24 months in mid-2025 to about 21 months, still above the 14-month target.
- Issue Fee to Grant: The Wait Has DoubledPatently-O ·
Patents now take about 60 days to issue after the issue fee is paid, twice the spring wait, apparently a queue left by the April allowance surge.
- Who Owns the Land Under the Trail?Patently-O ·
Federal Circuit holds a Florida railroad owned its corridor in fee, defeating Legacy Trail neighbors' takings claims under the Trails Act.
- Two Board Decisions Reaching Past the BriefsPatently-O ·
PTAB holds CBD formulation claims indefinite over a dual-role ingredient and treats an Apple claim's instruction to a phone as printed matter.
- Supreme Court Patent CasesPatently-O ·
Supreme Court denies VirtaMove without holding it for Tesla, Kahoot!, Intel, or FedEx. Plus new petitions on post-expiration royalties and § 101.
- PTAB Affirmance by Rejection Type, 2009–2026Patently-O ·
The PTAB affirms 84% of examiner Section 101 rejections but only 41% of anticipation rejections, and technology center moves the numbers too.
- Can Your Computer Corroborate Your Invention Date?Patently-O ·
Google v. Valtrus: Federal Circuit holds Word metadata can corroborate an inventor's conception testimony, while a § 101 dismissal still looms.
- PTAB Section 101 Appeal Data, 2009–2026Patently-O ·
I went back to 2009: Section 101 is again a fifth of PTAB appeals, the reversal spike faded, and the Board has nearly stopped raising 101 itself.
- Reading the Bench: Predictions for Five October Federal Circuit ArgumentsPatently-O ·
Blind AI readers forecast four pending Federal Circuit appeals, including Samsung v. ITC and Taylor Made v. Costco, after a Rule 36 in In re Burandt.
- A Toothbrush, a Lost Patent, and 170 Years of Claim DraftingPatently-O ·
Toothbrush patents reveal how claim drafting evolved from omnibus and Jepson claims to replacement heads, manufacturing, software, and sensors.
- Subject Matter Eligibility Declarations: An Empirical Study of Rule 132 Evidence and Examiner ResponsePatently-O ·
Of the 6,111 Rule 130, 131 and 132 declarations filed since the December memo, 460 are eligibility declarations, about 8%.
- Inter Partes Review (IPR) Filings Collapse to a New NormalPatently-O ·
FY2026 closed with about 450 IPR petitions, a third of FY2025. Institution decisions fell to 860, and the grant rate dropped from 69% to 39%.
- PTAB Law School Moot Court Competition Set for Spring 2027Patently-O ·
USPTO and IU Maurer announce a Spring 2027 PTAB Law School Moot Court Competition: one brief, APJ panels, and an in-person final in Alexandria.
- After Williamson: Who Changed Their Claims, and Where the Function WentPatently-O ·
New data on 8.75 million patents: means-plus-function claims are down to 3%, but functional claiming hit 74%. Who changed, and what replaced it?
- Jepson and Other Point-of-Novelty Claims in U.S. Patents, 1976–2026Patently-O ·
Point-of-novelty claims are rare: Jepson claims appear in 0.03% of U.S. patents, and the European two-part form in well under 1%.
- Out of Line: Chief Judge Moore Rebukes Counsel, Then Leans Toward Reversal in J&M v. KinzePatently-O ·
Chief Judge Moore rebukes J&M's counsel for touting credentials at Markman, yet the panel signals that "askewed angle" is broad, not indefinite.
- Parting Shot: Mandamus Sends USC v. Google from Judge Albright’s Austin Docket to N.D. Cal.Patently-O ·
Federal Circuit grants mandamus in In re Google, moving USC v. Google from Austin to N.D. Cal. weeks after Judge Albright left the bench.
- Pre-Suit Validity Investigation: When Must a Patentee Look Before Suing?Patently-O ·
In Epic Tech v. Pen-Tech, the Federal Circuit says the presumption of validity alone does not suffice when a patentee has notice of ineligibility.
- FY2026 Patent Data Update: Grants, Publications, and Cross-Border InventorsPatently-O ·
Final FY2026 numbers: 315,825 utility grants, continuing applications at 26% of grants, US-origin share at 39%, published applications down 6%, and cross-border inventor teams on a record 10.7% of patents.
- Ease Is Not Necessity: Third Circuit Affirms No Fair Use in Thomson Reuters v. ROSSPatently-O ·
Third Circuit affirms no fair use in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS: intermediate copying requires necessity, and generative AI is left for another case.
- Clear but Impossible: Satius v. Samsung Moves Inoperable Claims from Indefiniteness to EnablementPatently-O ·
Satius v. Samsung: a claim reciting an impossible alternative is definite, but the Federal Circuit holds it invalid for lack of enablement under Amgen.
- Method or Molecule: Judge Dyk Dissents from En Banc Denial in Teva v. LillyPatently-O ·
Federal Circuit denies en banc review in Teva v. Lilly over Judge Dyk's dissent, leaving method claims to an antibody genus intact after Amgen.
- One Determination, Two Clocks: Crocs Asks the Supreme Court to Fix ITC Appeal DeadlinesPatently-O ·
Crocs asks the Supreme Court whether one ITC determination can start two appeal clocks after the Federal Circuit dismissed its appeal as late.
- Tie Goes to the Applicant: The USPTO’s SMED FlowchartPatently-O ·
A new USPTO memo adds a flowchart for reviewing Subject Matter Eligibility Declarations, a SMED filing code, and a nod to disinterested declarants.
- This Is Not a Feature Vector: Zentian v. ApplePatently-O ·
Federal Circuit affirms cancellation of Zentian's speech-recognition patent, rejecting a Magritte analogy that codewords aren't feature vectors.
- Who Owns Mind Reading?Patently-O ·
Texas, UCSF, Siemens, and a London startup are staking patent claims on brain-to-text decoding. Older patents already cover pieces of the path.
- Before Lowell: The Patent System’s Early Rejection of Moral JudgmentPatently-O ·
In 1812 the Attorney General barred refusing patents on moral grounds, five years before Lowell v. Lewis. The patent issued ten days later.
- RCEs Are Rising Again: But Applicant Behavior Isn’t the Main CausePatently-O ·
RCE filings are rising again, driven largely by more USPTO final rejections, with the end of AFCP 2.0 also playing a role despite higher fees.
- The Federal Circuit Expands Its Jurisdiction Yet AgainPatently-O ·
Guest post by Paul R. Gugliuzza: the Federal Circuit's jurisdictional holding in Insulet v. EOFlow ignores Mottley's well-pleaded complaint rule.